Trusted, licensed movers - 100% free quotes
Looking for a best moving company in Fire Island Pines, NY? We make it simple to connect with licensed and insured movers who know the area and can handle every detail of your move. Our reliable Fire Island Pines movers can help pack, load, transport and also unpack your belongings, whether you're moving across town or across the country. Get customized moving quotes, find out specialized services like moving pianos or apartments, and hire a reliable local moving company in Fire Island Pines to make your move go smoothly, without any stress.
Fire Island Pines, NY
Thinking of moving to Fire Island Pines, NY? This unique beach community is home to about 300 seasonal residents (and a handful year-round), with a high median home price around $1.3 million and summer rentals topping $12,000/month for a 2-bedroom. Crime is extremely low, and the walkable lifestyle means your typical commute is a stroll to the ferry or beach. While schools and services are limited on-island, the area boasts scenic beaches, a vibrant social scene, and mild coastal weather—making it perfect for those seeking relaxation or a lively summer escape.
Fire Island Pines is a small, welcoming community with a peak summer population of about 300 and only a dozen year-round residents. The area skews older, with a median age of 54 and a predominantly White demographic, reflecting its appeal as a peaceful coastal getaway. The gender ratio is notably higher in males, and about 6% of residents speak a language other than English at home.
Living in Fire Island Pines comes with a high price tag, as the median home value stands at $1.3 million and seasonal summer rentals for a two-bedroom can reach $12,000 per month. The area’s cost of living index is 185, driven primarily by premium housing and transportation costs. Residents also face higher-than-average utilities and state taxes, making this community best suited for those seeking an upscale, seasonal lifestyle.
Fire Island Pines offers a remarkably safe environment, with a violent crime rate of just 60 per 100,000 and a property crime rate of 350 per 100,000 at peak season. The odds of experiencing violent crime are extremely low, at about 1 in 1,667, making this destination ideal for those valuing peace of mind. Property crime risks are also minimal, contributing to the area's relaxed atmosphere.
The Pines enjoys mild, coastal weather with warm summers averaging highs of 81°F and cool winters with lows around 28°F. Rainfall is moderate at 44 inches annually, and about 58% of days are sunny, providing plenty of opportunities for outdoor activities. The pleasant climate enhances the area’s reputation as a sought-after beach community.
Residents of Fire Island Pines and surrounding areas tend to have comfortable incomes, with a median household income near $98,000 and a low poverty rate of 7%. The community is highly educated, as 56% hold a bachelor’s degree or higher, and most people walk or take ferries rather than drive. The area’s relaxed pace and strong sense of community make it attractive for those seeking quality of life over urban hustle.
Educational options on Fire Island are limited, with the Woodhull School in nearby Ocean Beach serving younger students in small class settings and no private schools on the island. For higher education, Stony Brook University, a major public institution with over 26,000 students, is located 32 miles away on the mainland. Families may need to consider off-island schooling for broader academic opportunities.
Access to quality healthcare is readily available, with major hospitals such as Long Island Community Hospital and Stony Brook University Hospital located nearby on the mainland. The community enjoys a high rate of health insurance coverage at 94% and a strong physician presence, ensuring residents have essential medical services within reach. Emergency care and specialized treatments are accessible within a short ferry ride.
Fire Island Pines features a high-end, largely owner-occupied housing market, with a median home price of $1.3 million and very limited rental inventory outside peak season. Home values have appreciated by nearly 4% over the past year, and new construction is rare, reflecting the area’s exclusive and established nature. The market is ideal for buyers seeking a luxurious second home or seasonal retreat.
Residents and visitors rely on the New York State Department of Motor Vehicles for all licensing and registration needs, with the nearest office located in Commack, NY. Although most travel within the community is on foot or by ferry, DMV services are easily accessible for vehicle owners. For more information, the state DMV website and phone support are available.
Disclaimer: The information provided on this page is based on publicly available sources including AccuWeather, U.S. Census Bureau, local government data, and third-party partners such as Neustar. While we strive to ensure accuracy, all data is provided “as is” and should be independently verified before making any decisions. Movers.com makes no guarantees regarding the completeness or reliability of the information.
Whether it’s across town or just down the street, local movers nearby can make your move simple. Get a few quotes, read some reviews, and find a team that fits your requirements.
Need help beyond just local movers? Whether you're moving across town or cross-country, we've got the resources to support every type of relocation.
Visit our Fire Island Pines Moving Directory pageto browse all licensed movers and explore more services tailored to your needs.