Moving to Fire Island Pines, NY?

Fire Island Pines is a small, welcoming community with a peak summer population of about 300 and only a dozen year-round residents. The area skews older, with a median age of 54 and a predominantly White demographic, reflecting its appeal as a peaceful coastal getaway. The gender ratio is notably higher in males, and about 6% of residents speak a language other than English at home.

Population:

300 (seasonal peak), ~12 year-round

Density:

120 per sq mi (seasonal estimate)

Median Age:

54

Gender Ratio:

135 males per 100 females

Non-English Speakers Percentage:

6%

Ethnic Composition

White:

88%

Black:

2%

Asian:

3%

Others:

7%

Is Fire Island Pines, NY a safe place to live?

Fire Island Pines offers a remarkably safe environment, with a violent crime rate of just 60 per 100,000 and a property crime rate of 350 per 100,000 at peak season. The odds of experiencing violent crime are extremely low, at about 1 in 1,667, making this destination ideal for those valuing peace of mind. Property crime risks are also minimal, contributing to the area's relaxed atmosphere.

Violent Crimes Per 100k:

60

Property Crimes Per 100k:

350

Crime Index:

410

Chance Of Violent Crime:

1 in 1,667 (seasonal)

Chance Of Property Crime:

1 in 286

Residents of Fire Island Pines and surrounding areas tend to have comfortable incomes, with a median household income near $98,000 and a low poverty rate of 7%. The community is highly educated, as 56% hold a bachelor’s degree or higher, and most people walk or take ferries rather than drive. The area’s relaxed pace and strong sense of community make it attractive for those seeking quality of life over urban hustle.

Median Income:

$65,000

Household Income:

$98,000

Family Income:

$112,000

Per Capita Income:

$68,000

Income Male:

$75,000

Income Female:

$61,000

Poverty Rate:

7%

Non English Speakers:

6%

Rent:

$12,000/month (peak, 2BR)

Unemployment Rate:

4.6%

Public Transport Usage:

0% (primarily walking/ferry)

Commute Time:

10 minutes (walking; ferry to mainland ~20 min)

Education

High School or Higher:

96%

Bachelors or More:

56%

Access to quality healthcare is readily available, with major hospitals such as Long Island Community Hospital and Stony Brook University Hospital located nearby on the mainland. The community enjoys a high rate of health insurance coverage at 94% and a strong physician presence, ensuring residents have essential medical services within reach. Emergency care and specialized treatments are accessible within a short ferry ride.

Major Hospitals

Name:

Long Island Community Hospital

Address:

101 Hospital Road, Patchogue, NY 11772

Phone:

(631) 654-7100

Type:

General & Surgical

Emergency Services:

Yes

Name:

Stony Brook University Hospital

Address:

101 Nicolls Rd, Stony Brook, NY 11794

Phone:

(631) 444-4000

Type:

General & Trauma Center

Emergency Services:

Yes

Physicians Per 1000:

3.2

Health Insurance Coverage:

94%

Health Care Index:

77

Residents and visitors rely on the New York State Department of Motor Vehicles for all licensing and registration needs, with the nearest office located in Commack, NY. Although most travel within the community is on foot or by ferry, DMV services are easily accessible for vehicle owners. For more information, the state DMV website and phone support are available.

State:

New York

Department:

New York State Department of Motor Vehicles

Address:

250 Veteran's Memorial Hwy, Commack, NY 11725

Phone:

1-718-477-4820

Website:

https://dmv.ny.gov/