Everything You Should Know Before Moving to Fishers Island, NY
Thinking of moving to Fishers Island, NY? With a small, close-knit population of about 300, Fishers Island offers serene island living with a high median home price around $1.25M and average rents of $2,200. Crime rates are extremely low, with only 60 violent crimes per 100k, and the local Fishers Island School boasts a strong student-teacher ratio. Enjoy mild coastal weather, very short commutes, and a peaceful lifestyle—perfect if you value privacy, natural beauty, and a tight community.
Demographics - Fishers Island, NY
Demographics - Fishers Island, NY
Fishers Island is a small, close-knit community of around 300 residents, with a median age of 55 indicating a mature population. The area is predominantly White at 92%, with a balanced gender ratio and about 6% of the population speaking a language other than English at home. Its low population density offers a peaceful, spacious living environment.
Population:
300
Density:
70 per sq mi
Median Age:
55.0
Gender Ratio:
95 males per 100 females
Non-English Speakers Percentage:
6.0%
Ethnic Composition
White:
92.0%
Black:
2.0%
Asian:
1.5%
Others:
4.5%
Cost Of Living
What is the average cost of living in Fishers Island, NY?
The cost of living on Fishers Island is notably high, with a median home value of $1,250,000 and a cost of living index of 145, well above the national average. Housing and groceries are particularly expensive, and residents face higher-than-average utility and transportation costs. This exclusive island lifestyle comes at a premium but offers tranquility and privacy in return.
Median House Value:
$1,250,000
Gross Rent:
$2,200
Monthly Electricity Charges:
$170
Auto Insurance:
$2,300
House Owner Cost With Mortgage:
$3,400
House Owner Cost Without Mortgage:
$950
State Taxes:
Low:
4.0%
|
High:
10.9%
Cost Of Living Index:
145.0
Grocery:
139.0
Housing:
178.0
Utilities:
118.0
Transportation:
135.0
Health Care:
120.0
Miscellaneous:
115.0
Crime
Is Fishers Island, NY a safe place to live?
Fishers Island enjoys exceptionally low crime rates, with only 60 violent crimes and 430 property crimes per 100,000 residents. Your chance of experiencing violent crime is just 1 in 1,667, making it a very safe place to live. Residents can feel secure in this peaceful island community.
Violent Crimes Per 100k:
60
Property Crimes Per 100k:
430
Crime Index:
490
Chance Of Violent Crime:
1 in 1,667
Chance Of Property Crime:
1 in 233
Weather
What is the weather like in Fishers Island, NY year-round?
Fishers Island experiences mild coastal weather, with summer highs reaching 80°F and winter lows around 25°F. The area gets about 45 inches of rainfall annually and enjoys 58% sunny days, making it pleasant for outdoor activities year-round. The climate is ideal for those seeking gentle seasonal changes and abundant natural beauty.
Winter
Min:
25°F
Max:
38°F
Spring
Min:
42°F
Max:
62°F
Summer
Min:
60°F
Max:
80°F
Fall
Min:
45°F
Max:
68°F
Average Rainfall Inches:
44.8 inches
Sunny Days Percentage:
58%
Neighbors
Households in Fishers Island enjoy a median income of $95,000 and a low unemployment rate of 4.2%, reflecting a stable local economy. Most residents commute just 10 minutes, and nearly all have completed high school, with almost half holding a bachelor's degree or higher. The community is well-educated and affluent, with a strong sense of neighborly connection.
Median Income:
$41,000
Household Income:
$95,000
Family Income:
$110,000
Per Capita Income:
$54,000
Income Male:
$58,000
Income Female:
$46,000
Poverty Rate:
7.0%
Non English Speakers:
6.0%
Rent:
$2,200
Unemployment Rate:
4.2%
Public Transport Usage:
0.0%
Commute Time:
10.0 minutes
Education
High School or Higher:
95.0%
Bachelors or More:
45.0%
Education
How are the schools in Fishers Island, NY?
Fishers Island School provides education for local children with a very low student-teacher ratio of 6:1, ensuring personalized attention for its roughly 70 students. While there are no private schools on the island, nearby Connecticut College in New London offers higher education opportunities just 10 miles away by ferry. Families benefit from a tight-knit educational environment and easy access to additional academic resources.
Public Schools
Name:
Fishers Island School
Street:
78 Greenwood Rd
Phone:
631-788-7444
Students:
70
Student Teacher Ratio:
6.0
Colleges
Name:
Connecticut College
City:
New London
State:
CT
Distance:
10 miles (by ferry)
Students:
1,800
Healthcare
Residents have access to healthcare nearby at Lawrence + Memorial Hospital in New London, CT, offering emergency and general medical services. With 2.6 physicians per 1,000 people and 95% health insurance coverage, Fishers Island residents benefit from good healthcare availability. The area provides reliable care for a small community setting.
Major Hospitals
Name:
Lawrence + Memorial Hospital
Address:
365 Montauk Ave, New London, CT 06320
Phone:
(860) 442-0711
Type:
General & Surgical
Emergency Services:
Yes
Physicians Per 1000:
2.6
Health Insurance Coverage:
95.0%
Health Care Index:
78.0
Housing Market
What is the housing market like in Fishers Island, NY?
The housing market on Fishers Island is exclusive, with a median home price of $1,250,000 and over 87% of homes owner-occupied. Rent for a two-bedroom averages $2,200, and the area has seen healthy home appreciation of 6.2% in the past year. Limited new construction and low foreclosure rates contribute to a stable, high-value market.
Median Home Price:
$1,250,000
Average Rent For 2 Bedroom:
$2,200
Owner Occupied Rate:
87.0%
Rental Vacancy Rate:
11.0%
Home Appreciation Rate (1yr):
6.2%
New Construction Rate:
0.8%
Foreclosure Rate:
0.3%
DMV Information
As part of New York State, Fishers Island residents are served by the New York State Department of Motor Vehicles, with the nearest office located in Port Jefferson Station. DMV services such as licensing and vehicle registration are accessible, and residents can find more information at the official DMV website. Island-specific guidance may be available for ferry-related transportation needs.
State:
New York
Department:
New York State Department of Motor Vehicles
Address:
1001 NY-112, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776
Phone:
1-718-477-4820
Website:
Disclaimer: The information provided on this page is based on publicly available sources including AccuWeather, U.S. Census Bureau, local government data, and third-party partners such as Neustar. While we strive to ensure accuracy, all data is provided “as is” and should be independently verified before making any decisions. Movers.com makes no guarantees regarding the completeness or reliability of the information.