New York / County

Moving to Shelter Island, NY

Thinking of making a move to Shelter Island, NY? Get helpful local information about living costs, neighborhoods, schools, weather, housing, DMV details, and practical relocation details before you plan your move.

  • 100% Free Moving Quotes
  • No Obligation
  • Vetted & Licensed Movers
  • Secure & Private
Plan smarter before requesting quotes. Use local costs, housing, schools, safety, weather, and DMV details below to compare Shelter Island before you move.

Moving Help for Your Shelter Island, NY Relocation

After you review the local facts on this page, use the service links below to compare quote options for the type of Shelter Island move you are planning, including local, long-distance, apartment, piano, small, and budget-conscious moves.

Everything You Should Know Before Moving to Shelter Island, NY

Considering a move to Shelter Island, NY? This welcoming community of 2,400 residents offers a blend of suburban charm and convenience, with median home prices around $1,065,000 and average rents near $2,200. Commute times average 29 minutes and public transport is accessible, making it great for professionals. The area boasts low violent crime, strong schools, and plenty of sunny days (57% annually), ideal for families and commuters alike. Explore Shelter Island's cost of living, education, and friendly neighborhoods to see if it's the right fit for your next move.

Demographics - Shelter Island, NY

Shelter Island has a population of 2,400 residents, offering a diverse community with a median age of nearly 57 and a balanced gender ratio. The area features a strong blend of backgrounds, with about 92% White, 3% Black, and 2% Asian residents, and over 9% speaking a language other than English at home. Its high population density contributes to a lively suburban atmosphere.

Population
2,400
Density
210 per sq mi
Median Age
56.5
Gender Ratio
96 males per 100 females
Non-English Speakers Percentage
8.5%

Ethnic Composition

White
92.0%
Black
2.5%
Asian
1.5%
Others
4.0%

Cost Of Living

What is the average cost of living in Shelter Island, NY?

The cost of living in Shelter Island is higher than the national average, with a cost of living index of 178.5. Median home values are around $1,065,000 and average rents for a two-bedroom apartment are approximately $2,200. Utilities, groceries, and transportation costs are also elevated, reflecting the area's desirable location and amenities.

Median House Value
$1,065,000
Gross Rent
$2,200
Monthly Electricity Charges
$180
Auto Insurance
$1,950
House Owner Cost With Mortgage
$2,950
House Owner Cost Without Mortgage
$980
State Taxes
Low: 4.0%| High: 10.9%
Cost Of Living Index
178.5
Grocery
133.0
Housing
245.0
Utilities
121.0
Transportation
135.5
Health Care
118.0
Miscellaneous
112.0

Crime

Is Shelter Island, NY a safe place to live?

Shelter Island is considered a safe community, with a low violent crime rate of 70 incidents per 100,000 residents and a property crime chance of 1 in 470. Most residents enjoy peace of mind, making it an attractive choice for families. The crime index remains below many urban areas in New York.

Violent Crimes Per 100k
70
Property Crimes Per 100k
510
Crime Index
580
Chance Of Violent Crime
1 in 1,430
Chance Of Property Crime
1 in 470

Weather

What is the weather like in Shelter Island, NY year-round?

Shelter Island experiences four distinct seasons, with warm summers reaching highs of 81°F and cold winters dipping to 26°F. The area receives about 45 inches of rainfall annually and enjoys sunshine on 57% of days. This climate offers residents a balanced mix of outdoor opportunities year-round.

Winter

Min
26°F
Max
39°F

Summer

Min
65°F
Max
81°F

Spring

Min
42°F
Max
63°F

Fall

Min
48°F
Max
70°F
Average Rainfall Inches
45.3 inches
Sunny Days Percentage
57%

Neighbors

The neighborhood boasts a healthy median household income of $98,200 and a low poverty rate of 6.7%. Over 95% of residents have at least a high school diploma, and nearly 44% hold a bachelor's degree or higher. Commute times average 29 minutes, and almost 2% use public transportation, reflecting the area's accessibility and educated population.

Median Income
$45,000
Household Income
$98,200
Family Income
$107,000
Per Capita Income
$52,500
Income Male
$58,000
Income Female
$45,000
Poverty Rate
6.7%
Non English Speakers
8.5%
Rent
$2,200
Unemployment Rate
3.9%
Public Transport Usage
1.8%
Commute Time
29.4 minutes

Education

High School or Higher
94.5%
Bachelors or More
44.0%

Education

How are the schools in Shelter Island, NY?

Shelter Island offers quality education options, with public schools like Shelter Island School known for favorable student-to-teacher ratios. Families also have access to private schools and several nearby colleges, including Stony Brook University and Suffolk County Community College - Eastern Campus. The community is committed to educational excellence for all age groups.

Public Schools

Name
Shelter Island School
Street
33 N Ferry Rd
Phone
631-749-0302
Students
210
Student Teacher Ratio
6.9

Colleges

Name
Stony Brook University
City
Stony Brook
State
NY
Distance
34 miles
Students
26,700
Name
Suffolk County Community College - Eastern Campus
City
Riverhead
State
NY
Distance
21 miles
Students
4,800

Healthcare

Shelter Island residents have access to quality healthcare, with major hospitals like Eastern Long Island Hospital and Stony Brook Southampton Hospital nearby. The community benefits from a high physician-to-resident ratio of 2.7 per 1,000 people and 95.2% health insurance coverage. Local healthcare services are reliable and comprehensive.

Major Hospitals

Name
Eastern Long Island Hospital
Address
201 Manor Pl, Greenport, NY 11944
Phone
(631) 477-1000
Type
General & Surgical
Emergency Services
Yes
Name
Stony Brook Southampton Hospital
Address
240 Meeting House Ln, Southampton, NY 11968
Phone
(631) 726-8200
Type
General & Surgical
Emergency Services
Yes

Healthcare Access

Physicians Per 1000
2.7
Health Insurance Coverage
95.2%
Health Care Index
77.3

Housing Market

What is the housing market like in Shelter Island, NY?

The local housing market is strong, with a median home price of $1,065,000 and an owner-occupied rate of nearly 79%. The market has seen a 6.3% appreciation over the past year, and rental vacancy rates remain moderate at 7.1%. Shelter Island offers a mix of stability and opportunity for both buyers and renters.

Median Home Price
$1,065,000
Average Rent For 2 Bedroom
$2,200
Owner Occupied Rate
79.4%
Rental Vacancy Rate
7.1%
Home Appreciation Rate (1yr)
6.3%
New Construction Rate
0.8%
Foreclosure Rate
0.4%

DMV Information

Residents of Shelter Island handle vehicle services through the New York State Department of Motor Vehicles, conveniently located in Medford. The state DMV provides driver licensing, vehicle registration, and other essential services both in person and online. Information and resources are easily accessible for new and existing residents.

State
New York
Department
New York State Department of Motor Vehicles
Address
2799 Route 112, Medford, NY 11763
Phone
1-718-477-4820

Disclaimer: The information provided on this page is based on publicly available sources including AccuWeather, U.S. Census Bureau, local government data, and third-party partners such as Neustar. While we strive to ensure accuracy, all data is provided “as is” and should be independently verified before making any decisions. Movers.com makes no guarantees regarding the completeness or reliability of the information.

FAQs About Moving to Shelter Island, NY

Answers use the same city data shown on this page, including costs, housing, schools, safety, weather, healthcare, and DMV details.

Before moving to Shelter Island, review the core fields on this page: population 2,400, median home value $1,065,000, average rent for 2 bedroom $2,200, commute time 29.4 minutes, and sunny days percentage 57%.

Ready to Move to Shelter Island, NY?

When your relocation research is done, request quote options and plan your move with confidence.

Get Free Moving Quotes